it was ok. Garlic bread was yesterdays fresh bread. but hey. what do you expect. its a pizza place. The baked ziti was ok, but the noodles were too soft to pick up with a fork most of the time. Half of them the fork just slid through the noodle. I'd order from them again, but maybe I'd stick to the pizza.

Posted a month ago by Steven S.

If they deliver your order in less than an hour then the pizza/food is about room temp. They will forget your soda, meatballs, or any other extra and when you call back to ask for them not to charge you they will tell you you get a discount on your next order.... So doesn't really work on Seamless. I have ordered from them too many times and every time it's been upsetting... too bad the few times the food was warm it was good.

Posted 4 months ago by Crystie N.

Once again, they sent the wrong food. The girl laughed and her biggest concern was whether she could recoup the meatball sub (I ordered chicken parm). Third time I have order blue cheese with salad and received Italian dressing. She said they dont have blue cheese. I said take it off the menu then. She checked. "Oh, maybe we do have blue cheese." I am sorry but don't reward bad behavior by supporting Bleecker Street Pizza.

Posted 4 months ago by Robert L.

Called after an hour to ask where my order was; they told me it wouldn't even go out for another half hour after that. Is melted cheese on bread really so complicated? There are so many other good pizza joints in the neighborhood, don't bother dealing with these guys.

Posted 5 months ago by Sally R.

The pizza was tasteless and as hard as the cardboard box it arrived in. The chicken roll was not what you would expect when ordering a chicken roll. It was made with lemon and parsley chicken and had no marinara sauce. The wings were dry. Everything tasted as if it had been sitting around for a few hours. Also, the food took 50 mins to arrive. Will not order again.

Posted 6 months ago by Frank G.

I am back living in the West Village (thank god) and friends kept telling me to skip Joe's and try Bleecker Street Pizza. It took a few months but I have to admit they were right. My new favorite pizza shop is definately Bleecker Street and my favorite slice is the fresh mozz, they call it the Nonna Maria,whatever. Best slice I have ever had,period.

Posted 6 months ago by bobby p.

Best pizza in nyc hands down

Posted 6 months ago by Ryan K.

Pizza came burnt. And they were total jerks when I called them up about it. Inexcusable.

Posted 8 months ago by Brian S.

The pizza was fine, nothing special. The onions I paid $3.00 for were forgotten from our pizza and the delivery came in 45 minutes not 15-30. The sausage sandwich I ordered came with mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce even though the cheese was not listed on the menu. There was way too much sauce resulting in a soggy mess that while somewhat tasty, was falling apart and impossible to pick up.

Posted 8 months ago by elizabeth c.

Six years living in west village, this is the best pizza hands down.Try the Nona Marie pie (best sauce I have ever had- they should sell it bottled). Other favorites - Mushroom pizza (fresh mushrooms not canned) great plain pizza and toppings. Their heros are more than a meal and great house salad for a pizza place (or any restaurant).

Posted 8 months ago by mike m.

Sauce is perfect, but the dough was rock hard.

Posted 9 months ago by Ryan H.

As a native New Yorker I was extremely disappointed with this place. The order took nearly an hour to arrive and when it did the cheese had completely slid off the pizza! It was like eating pizza soup in a box. So very upset, I had heard good things about this place and as I am new to this neighborhood I can say I will look elsewhere for pizza. Extremely bummed, and will never order from this place again.

Posted 10 months ago by Katie A.

Phenomenal. Best pizza I ever had., The sauce is to die for. The crust is the best I've ever had.

Posted a year ago by jodie r.

Amazing Baked Ziti-have to try it!!

Posted a year ago by Danica W.

Bleeker Street is our favorite pizza place in the village. We order the Nonna Maria every Friday (Pizza Day!!). The sauce to cheese to crust ratio is perfect on this pizza. Their chicken rolls are also great, but make sure to ask for extra marinara sauce on the side. The sauce is really delicious and they give it to you free (if you call and ask nicely).

Posted a year ago by Stacey K.

Hands down the best pizza in NYC (which means any where). Try the fresh mozz pie they call Nona Maria.

Posted a year ago by bobby .

Excellent pizza. The round "nonna's pizza" is great but the square is even better.

Posted a year ago by Timothy P.

I heard all the hype- Jimmie Kimmel, the food Network et al. It was all that and then some. Try the nona maria pie- fresh mozz and the best sauce I have ever had on pizza or anything else for that matter.

Posted a year ago by tony s.

AMAZING! FINALLY THEY ARE ON SEAMLESSWEB!!! BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA IN NY IF NOT THE EAST COAST. WHY? JUST TASTE! THEY TEND TO EACH DETAIL AND I MUST SAY, IT'S GREAT TO HAVE A DELIVERY PERSON WHO ACTUALLY SPEAKS ENGLISH AND DOESN'T DEMAND EXTRA TIP LIKE THE OTHER PIZZA PLACES! THANK YOU!!! EGGPLANT PIZZA JUST LIKE MY NONNA MADE!!! GOODBYE TWO BOOTS, GOOD BYE PIZZA PARADISE WITH MEAN SHORT DELIVERY MAN!!!! HELLO BLEECKER STREET!!!! (AND THEY BROUGHT ME NAPKINS TOO---GOODBYE DOMINO!!!!) GRAZIE!

Posted a year ago by ARTURO S.